Exploring the Neversink: A Journey Along the 'Water Between the Highlands'

The Neversink River, a name resonating with fly fishing history, weaves its way through the scenic landscapes of New York. This river tells a story of both tailwater trout fishing and the charm of freestone streams. Its waters have witnessed the footsteps of pioneers and anglers, creating a legacy that spans generations.

The Neversink River’s lower headwater section is home to brown trout, where a six-mile tailwater section from Woodburne to the dam invites anglers to decipher its secrets. Unlike other tailwaters, this stretch boasts slow-moving pools with gentle riffles, offering a unique fishing experience. Here, patience and finesse reign supreme.

Fly fishing the Neversink River requires an understanding of its diverse inhabitants. Small flies are the key, particularly midge imitations ranging from hook size 18 down to 26. Observing trout feeding behavior is vital, as surface feeding isn’t always the norm. Midge patterns and subsurface nymphs often hold the key to success.

Venturing into the upper branches of the East and West Branches of the Neversink reveals a realm of brook trout. The river is predominantly private, save for the uppermost reaches of both branches on state land, accessible only by hiking and known for small wild brook trout. Public fishing is limited to two brief sections on the West Branch near the Frost Valley YMCA Camp. These small, vibrant fish lend a touch of nostalgia to the river, harking back to its historical significance in fly fishing literature.

The Neversink River carries the echoes of its fly fishing heritage. It was home to Theodore Gordon and other early fly fishing luminaries, making it not just a fishing spot, but a sanctuary for the soul of fly fishing.

Navigating the Neversink requires versatility. Tailwater and freestone sections call for distinct strategies. Midge imitations, nymphs, and caddisfly patterns often take precedence. Mornings and evenings present opportunities for streamer fishing, while terrestrials lure trout during low light conditions.

The Neversink River, with its dual identities, tells a tale of history and nature’s wonders. As you cast your line into its waters, you become part of a legacy that celebrates the art of fly fishing and the beauty of the outdoors.

Join us in discovering the Neversink River, where waters flow with tradition and trout, and where every cast connects you to a legacy of anglers past and present.